6

In a previous post entitled "Symbols for Outer Joins" a solution was given to produce outer join symbols.

However, this solution generates an error when, e.g., $R \leftouterjoin S$ is used in a caption.

Any solution for this ?

\documentclass[a4paper,10pt]{article}

\usepackage{latexsym}

% Definition of outer joins

\def\ojoin{\setbox0=\hbox{$\Join$}
\rule[0.10ex]{.3em}{.4pt}\llap{\rule[1.40ex]{.3em}{.4pt}}}
\def\leftouterjoin{\mathrel{\ojoin\mkern-6.5mu\Join}}
\def\rightouterjoin{\mathrel{\Join\mkern-6.5mu\ojoin}}
\def\fullouterjoin{\mathrel{\ojoin\mkern-6.5mu\Join\mkern-6.5mu\ojoin}}

\begin{document}

The outer join symbols work great in text: $R\rightouterjoin S$, $R\leftouterjoin S$, $R\fullouterjoin S$. 
However, it generates the error \verb+Argument of \@caption has an extra }.+ when used in captions.

\begin{figure} 
\centering
This a figure
\caption{$R\rightouterjoin S$}
\end{figure} 

\end{document}
Improve this question
4
  • try inserting \protect just before that command.
    – barbara beeton
    Oct 19, 2013 at 14:48
  • Alas it does not solve the problem when I put \caption{\protect $R\rightouterjoin S$}
    – Esteban Zimanyi
    Oct 19, 2013 at 15:02
  • It needs to precede your command: \caption{$R\protect\rightouterjoin S$}
    – Pedro
    Oct 19, 2013 at 15:10
  • 1
    i meant \protect\rightouterjoin. the \protect must be immediately before the command (and it's always a command) that is causing the trouble. or you could define the command as "robust"; check this forum for how to do that.
    – barbara beeton
    Oct 19, 2013 at 15:11

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
6

If you define \ojoin to be robust then there is no problem:

Sample output

\documentclass[a4paper,10pt]{article}

\usepackage{latexsym}

% Definition of outer joins

\DeclareRobustCommand{\ojoin}{\rule[0.10ex]{.3em}{.4pt}\llap{\rule[1.40ex]{.3em}{.4pt}}}
\newcommand{\leftouterjoin}{\mathrel{\ojoin\mkern-6.5mu\Join}}
\newcommand{\rightouterjoin}{\mathrel{\Join\mkern-6.5mu\ojoin}}
\newcommand{\fullouterjoin}{\mathrel{\ojoin\mkern-6.5mu\Join\mkern-6.5mu\ojoin}}

\begin{document}
\show\ojoin
The outer join symbols work great in text: $R\rightouterjoin S$, $R\leftouterjoin S$, $R\fullouterjoin S$. 
However, it generates the error \verb+Argument of \@caption has an extra }.+ when used in captions.

\begin{figure} 
\centering
This a figure
\caption{$R\rightouterjoin S$}
\end{figure} 

\end{document}

The problem is that \rule is a fragile command in LaTeX and needs to either be \protected or make robust for use in captions. Cf. What is the difference between Fragile and Robust commands?

Improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .