6

I'm using the bnf package to format a context-free grammar in one of my documents. I'm finding that any whitespace will be reflected in the output. I would like to keep the whitespace in the code for readability but have it removed in the output. Is there a way to make this happen?

\documentclass[leqno,fleqn,12pt]{report}

\usepackage{bnf}

\begin{document}

\begin{grammar}
[(colon){$\rightarrow$}]
[(semicolon)$|$]
[(comma){}]
[(period){\\}]
[(quote){\begin{bf}}{\end{bf}}]
[(nonterminal){$\langle$}{$\rangle$}]

<rule-working>:<formats>,<correctly>;<without>,<whitespace>.
<rule-not-working> : <formats> , <incorrectly> ; <with> , <whitespace> .

\end{grammar}

\end{document}

Example

8

The command \catcode32=9\relax (or \catcode`\ =9\relax) will make TeX ignore all spaces in the current group/environment. You could define your own environment and add it and {grammar} to it.

\documentclass[leqno,fleqn,12pt]{report}

\usepackage{bnf}

\newenvironment{Grammar}{%
\catcode32=9\relax
\begin{grammar}%
}{%
\end{grammar}
}

\begin{document}

% Either
\begin{grammar}
[(colon){$\rightarrow$}]
[(semicolon)$|$]
[(comma){}]
[(period){\\}]
[(quote){\begin{bf}}{\end{bf}}]
[(nonterminal){$\langle$}{$\rangle$}]
\catcode32=9\relax

<rule-working>:<formats>,<correctly>;<without>,<whitespace>.
<rule-not-working> : <formats> , <incorrectly> ; <with> , <whitespace> .

\end{grammar}

% or
\begin{Grammar}
[(colon){$\rightarrow$}]
[(semicolon)$|$]
[(comma){}]
[(period){\\}]
[(quote){\begin{bf}}{\end{bf}}]
[(nonterminal){$\langle$}{$\rangle$}]

<rule-working>:<formats>,<correctly>;<without>,<whitespace>.
<rule-not-working> : <formats> , <incorrectly> ; <with> , <whitespace> .

\end{Grammar}

\end{document}

Result

As Joseph Wright pointed out there are more space-like characters you might also want to ignore:

\catcode9=9\relax     % Horizontal Tab
\endlinechar=-1\relax % No line endings

A space or non-expandable TeX command like \relax must follow the number so TeX knows to stop reading digits.

and maybe these (just to be on the save side):

\catcode10=9 %   New line
\catcode11=9 %   Vertical Tab 
\catcode12=9 %   Form Feed
\catcode13=9 %   Carriage Return
  • 1
    You'd probably want to cover tabs as well, plus make line-ends disappear (\endlinechar=-1\relax). – Joseph Wright Mar 5 '11 at 21:58
  • @Joseph: Indeed, I added these now plus some more. – Martin Scharrer Mar 5 '11 at 22:05
  • @Joseph why not enclose it in ExplSyntaxOn ...ExplSyntaxOff, it is much simpler. – Yiannis Lazarides Mar 6 '11 at 3:26
  • @Yiannis, in case you don't know: Joseph wasn't notified of your comment; only the first "@" does this. If your had exchanged Martin und Joseph, both would have gotten a notification since the author of the post is always notified. – Hendrik Vogt Mar 6 '11 at 7:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.