Layout guidelines not exactly a multiple of \baselineskip

Question

Many conferences in my area require that papers be submitted on letter paper (8.5" x 11") with 1" margins and a 12pt leading. So we end up with 9" for text. (I'm sure there's a name for that, but it is escaping me.) This gives us 9 in * 72.27 pt/in = 650.43 pt. If we subtract TeX's default \topskip = 10 pt for the top line, that gives us 640.43 pt for a little more than 54.3691 lines including the first line.

In a one column document, this is typically not an issue since there will be many paragraph breaks between which the extra (approximately) 0.3691 lines can go. In a two column document, this becomes fairly noticeable, especially with long paragraphs. See

\documentclass[twocolumn]{article}
\usepackage{lipsum}
\usepackage[margin=1in]{geometry}
\begin{document}
\lipsum
\lipsum
\end{document}

for an example which isn't terrible, but quite noticeable.

One option is to set \topskip=14.43 pt. Another option would be to make the bottom margin 76.7 pt. A third option would be to modify both \topskip and the bottom margin. A fourth option (which I have used for all of my papers until now) is to just ignore it as it seems highly likely that no one on the program committee will notice and it's certainly not going to make a difference to my acceptance/rejection.

Is there a recommended way to handle this?

Answer 1

Add heightrounded to your \usepackage{geometry}. It basically modifies the bottom margin automatically.

Answer 2

A good approach is to use the techniques, outlined in the grid package. This package has been described in the TUGBoat article Mimicking Traditional Typesetting and is available in ctan. You do not only need to worry about text, but also figures and equations, which they all have to be multiples of the baseline.

Answer 3

Would it be a serious typographical mistake to add the additional space to the leading? With \baselineskip=12.0835pt (after \begin{document}!) I get nicely aligned lines in your example.