This is exercise 12.17

(This is a sequel to exercise 12.2, but it's trickier.) Describe the result of \line{\hfil A puzzle.\hfilneg}

This is exercise 12.2

Describe the result of \line{\hfil\hfil What happens now?\hfil} \line{\hfill\hfil and now?\hfil}

The answer to exercise 12.17 reads:

... (In this case, TeX's rule about infinite glue differs from what you would get in the limit if the value of 1 fil were finite but getting larger and larger. The true limiting behavior would stretch the text `A puzzle.' in the same way, but it would also move that text infinitely far away beyond the right edge of the page.)

Example from the question is equivalent to this:

\hbox to\hsize {\hskip 0pt plus 1fil A puzzle.\hskip 0pt plus -1fil}

How in terms of this does one interpret the words "if the value of 1 fil were finite" and "true limiting behavior"?


\hfilneg isn't a minus value but rather a negative plus value:

\hbox to\hsize {\hskip 0pt plus 0pt A puzzle.\hskip 0pt plus -0pt}

\hbox to\hsize {\hskip 0pt plus 10pt B puzzle.\hskip 0pt plus -10pt}

\hbox to\hsize {\hskip 0pt plus 100pt C puzzle.\hskip 0pt plus -100pt}

\hbox to\hsize {\hskip 0pt plus 1000pt D puzzle.\hskip 0pt plus -1000pt}

\hbox to\hsize {\hskip 0pt plus 1fil E puzzle.\hskip 0pt plus -1fil}

\hbox to\hsize {\hfil F puzzle.\hfilneg}


Note the last two examples E and F are the same, but the point is they do not correspond to the limiting case of A-D as the finite skip gets larger.

enter image description here

  • Fixed the question. BTW, should "was" be used instead of "were" in the answer? (because the concept of 1fil is regarded here as a singular thing) Aug 26 '15 at 23:09
  • @IgorLiferenko were is OK here it's not singular/plural but rather the conditional would .. if ... were (but don't ask an Englishman about English grammar:-) Aug 26 '15 at 23:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.