10

I need to perform a string comparison (string equality). If the macro is non-expandable (e.g. contains \def or \let), it causes problems in the place where it is used.

I tried using \ifthenelse from the package with the same name, but it would seem it is not expandable (the same problems as when I use \def in the macro occur).

\ifthenelse{\equal{a}{b}}{if-case}{else-case}

How can I test the equality of two strings (#1 and a constant, for that matter) in an expandable way?

3
  • package xstring
    – touhami
    Apr 26, 2016 at 17:37
  • @touhami the IfStrEq command is not expandable. From the xstring docs: "The macros of this package are not purely expandable". I tried it and it produces the same problem as ifthenelse. Apr 26, 2016 at 17:44
  • Sorry I don't know, I just thinked it can be helpfull.
    – touhami
    Apr 26, 2016 at 18:22

2 Answers 2

7

You can use expl3; the \strcompare macro is just a user level version of the expandable internal function \str_if_eq:nnTF.

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{expl3}

\ExplSyntaxOn
\cs_new_eq:NN \strcompare \str_if_eq:nnTF
\ExplSyntaxOff

\begin{document}

start\par
\strcompare{abc}{def}{OOPS}{OK}\par
\strcompare{abc}{abcd}{OOPS}{OK}\par
\strcompare{abcd}{abc}{OOPS}{OK}\par
\strcompare{a}{}{OOPS}{OK}\par
\strcompare{}{a}{OOPS}{OK}\par
end

\medskip

start\par
\strcompare{abc}{abc}{OK}{OOPS}\par
\strcompare{}{}{OK}{OOPS}\par
end

\end{document}

enter image description here

4

I've read that with \usepackage{pdftexcmds}, you can use \pdf@strcmp but haven't checked if it works in this case.

Alternatively, the code below defines \expandable@if@equal{str1}{str2}{if-case}{else-case}. As @JavierBezos noted in the comments, spaces are not taken into account (so "a b" = "ab"), and a version which takes them into account would be harder to achieve (if at all possible?). It can be used as follows:

\makeatletter
start%
\expandable@if@equal{abc}{def}{OOPS}{OK}%
\expandable@if@equal{abc}{abcd}{OOPS}{OK}%
\expandable@if@equal{abcd}{abc}{OOPS}{OK}%
\expandable@if@equal{a}{}{OOPS}{OK}%
\expandable@if@equal{}{a}{OOPS}{OK}%
end

start%
\expandable@if@equal{abc}{abc}{OK}{OOPS}%
\expandable@if@equal{}{}{OK}{OOPS}%
end
\makeatother

Which prints (notice that no extraneous space gets inserted):

startOKOKOKOKOKend
startOKOKend

Here's the definition of \expandable@if@equal:

\makeatletter

%         #1       #2          #3    #4                                  \sepend
% Params: {if-case}{else-case} \sepr \sepr                               \sepend
% Or:     {if-case}{else-case} B     right-…(may be *nothing*)\sepr\sepr \sepend
\def\@expandable@if@equal@empty#1#2#3#4\sepend{%
  \ifx#3\sepr% #3right… = Empty string, a.k.a. "\sepr"
    % First case in the signature above (#3=\sepr, #4=sepr)
    #1% The strings are both empty, and therefore equal. Execute #1.
  \else%
    % Second case in the signature above (#3=one char, #4=right…\sepr\sepr)
    #2% The right string is longer (there's at least one more character), so they are different. Execute #2.
  \fi%
}%
%         #1       #2         #3          #4       \sepl #5    #6                        \sepr #7        \sepend
% Params: {if-case}{else-case}{left-first}{left-…} \sepl \sepr *nothing*                 \sepr *nothing* \sepend
% Or:     {if-case}{else-case}{left-first}{left-…} \sepl B     right-…(may be *nothing*) \sepr \sepr     \sepend
\def\@expandable@if@equal@somechar#1#2#3#4\sepl#5#6\sepr#7\sepend{%
  \ifx#5\sepr% #5#6 = Empty string, a.k.a. "\sepr"
    % First case in the signature above (#5=\sepr, #6=*nothing*, #7=*nothing*)
    #2% But the left string was not empty, so we run else-case
  \else%
    % Second case in the signature above (#5=one char, #6=right…, #7=\sepr)
    \ifx#3#5% First character of left == first character of right
      \@expandable@if@equal{#1}{#2}#4\sepl\sepl#6\sepr\sepr\sepend% Recursion on the rest
    \else%
      #2% The strings are different at this character, execute #2.
    \fi%
  \fi%
}%
% Two possibilities:
%               #1       #2          #3    #4                       \sepl #5          \sepend
% \@expandable@if@equal {if-case}{else-case} \sepl *nothing*                \sepl <rest>      \sepend
% \@expandable@if@equal {if-case}{else-case} A     left-…(may be *nothing*) \sepl \sepl<rest> \sepend
\def\@expandable@if@equal#1#2#3#4\sepl#5\sepend{%
  \ifx#3\sepl% #3#4 = Empty string, a.k.a. "\sepl"
    % First case in the signature above (#3=\sepl, #4=*nothing*, #5=<rest>)
    \@expandable@if@equal@empty{#1}{#2}#5\sepend%
  \else%
    % First case in the signature above (#3=one char, #4=left…, #5=\sepl<rest>)
    \@expandable@if@equal@somechar{#1}{#2}{#3}{#4}#5\sepend%
  \fi%
}
\def\expandable@if@equal#1#2#3#4{%
  % \@expandable@if@equal#1\sepl#4%#2\sepl#4
  %
  % \@expandable@if@equal{#4}\sepl\sepl%
  \@expandable@if@equal{#3}{#4}#1\sepl\sepl#2\sepr\sepr\sepend%
}%

\makeatother
1
  • Unfortunately spaces are ignored ("a b" = "ab"). Jul 10, 2016 at 9:09

This site is temporarily in read-only mode and not accepting new answers.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .