RFC: Node relative coordinate system in TikZ

Question

I was dissatisfied with the implicit degree anchors TikZ provides for nodes (i.e., (node.30)). I often want to start an path at 30 percent from the left at the lower border of a node. This is of course possible with calc, but this feels a little clumsy.

Therefore, I wrote a snippet that defines a node relative coordinate system and hooked it into the parser to provide a convenient syntax. After some usage, I found it so useful that I would like to show it and request some feedback, before sending it to the PGF/TikZ maintainers.

The resulting syntax for 20 percent at the bottom is (NODE:20,0). What do you think?

\documentclass[crop,tikz]{standalone}

\makeatletter

% Declare a relative coordinate system, that is relative to the edges
% of a given node.
\tikzdeclarecoordinatesystem{rel}{%
    \tikzset{cs/.cd,x=0pt,y=0pt,#1}%
    \pgfpointlineattime{(\tikz@cs@x / 100)}%
       {\pgfpointanchor{\tikz@pp@name{\tikz@cs@node}}{south west}}%
       {\pgfpointanchor{\tikz@pp@name{\tikz@cs@node}}{south east}}%
    \edef\tikz@cs@x{\the\pgf@x}%
    \pgfpointlineattime{(\tikz@cs@y / 100)}%
       {\pgfpointanchor{\tikz@pp@name{\tikz@cs@node}}{south west}}%
       {\pgfpointanchor{\tikz@pp@name{\tikz@cs@node}}{north west}}%
    \pgfpoint{\tikz@cs@x}{\pgf@y}%
  }

% Hook into Tikz coordinate parse to provide (<name>:<rel x>x<rel y>)
\def\tikz@parse@relcs#1(#2:#3,#4){%
\tikz@parse@coordinatesystem#1(rel cs:name={#2},x={#3},y={#4})%
}
\let\tikz@parse@relcs@polar@saved=\tikz@parse@polar
\def\tikz@parse@polar#1(#2:#3){%
  \pgfutil@in@{,}{#3}%
  \ifpgfutil@in@%
    \let\@next\tikz@parse@relcs%
  \else%
    \let\@next\tikz@parse@relcs@polar@saved%
  \fi%
  \@next#1(#2:#3)%
}

\makeatother


\begin{document}
\begin{tikzpicture}
  % First we define a border node, that we use as coordinate system
  \node[draw, text width=100mm, align=center, text height=40mm, text depth=40mm](border){};
  % Just some coordinate system
  \foreach \x in {10,20,30,40,50,60,70,80,90} {
    \draw[black!20] (border:\x,100) -- (border:\x,0) node[black,anchor=north] {\x};
    \draw[black!20] (border:0,\x) -- (border:100,\x) node[black,anchor=west] {\x};
  }


  % Use the explicit coordinate syntax
  \draw (rel cs:x=50,y=0,name=border) -- (rel cs:x=75,y=100,name=border);

  % Use the shorthand version that is hooked into the TiKZ coordinate
  % parser.
  \node at (border:20,30) (A) {A};
  \node at (border:50,75) (B) {B};

  % Some more nice demonstrations
  \node[draw] at (border:25,75) (text) {Long-Text};
  \draw (text:20,0) edge[->,bend right] (A);
  \draw (text:60,0) edge[->,bend right] (B.south);
  \foreach \x in {10,20,30,40,50,60,70,80,90} {
    \draw (text:\x,100) -- ++(up:5pt);
  }

  % Polar Coordinates still work
  \draw (0,0) -- (30:2cm);

 \end{tikzpicture}
\end{document}

Answer 1

This is a long comment.

Recall that TikZ parses (something) as follows:

• Check if it involves calculation ($(U)+(V)$)
• Check if it is of specific coordinate system (foo cs: bar)
• Check if it is an intersection (intersection-1) & (A|-B)
• Check if it polar or cartesian coordinate (1:2) & (3,4)
• Check if it is a pre-defined node (node)
• Check if it is a node with a predefined anchor (node.anchor)
• Check if it is a node with an angle (node.360)

So there are two possibilities:

• If a node is very important, (current page) for instance, then one can make it a coordinate system: (current page cs: bar bar bar). (see this)
• If all nodes are equal, then it should be part of the node-anchor system: The expected syntax are (node.360) and (node.{12,34}).

Recall that although a node in TikZ (a shape in PGF) can have many many anchors, it is not always satisfying. Hence PGF introduces border anchor so that one can create anchors on the fly. Similarly one could create an interior anchor system parallel to border anchors.

By the way, PGF introduces generic anchor that creates anchors for all nodes. For example if you want a point "at 30 percent from the left at the lower border of a node", you can write

\documentclass[border=9,tikz]{standalone}
\begin{document}
\makeatletter
\pgfdeclaregenericanchor{30 from left on bottom}{
    \pgf@process{\northeast}
    \pgf@xa=.3\pgf@x
    \pgf@process{\southwest}
    \pgf@x=.7\pgf@x
    \advance\pgf@x by\pgf@xa
}
\makeatother
\tikz{
    \path[nodes=draw]node(A){Apple}(5,0)node(B){Banana};
    \draw[bend right](A.30 from left on bottom)to(B.30 from left on bottom);
}
\end{document}