Align two inequalities

Question

I am trying to align two inequlities vertically. The \le signs should have the same horizontal positions and the term in the should be centered. My first attempt:

\begin{align*}
\sum a &\le \sum b &\le \sum c \\
\log \sum a &\le \log \sum b &\le \log \sum c
\end{align*}

Doesn't work. My second attempt:

\[
\begin{array}{rcccl}
\sum a &\le& \sum b &\le& \sum c \\
\log \sum a &\le& \log \sum b &\le& \log \sum c
\end{array}
\]

The alignment is good, but the sum signs are smaller than in the align environment.

What is the "best" way to do this LaTeX?

Answer 1

alignat is your friend:

\begin{alignat*}{2}
\sum a &\le &\sum b &\le \sum c \\
\log \sum a &\le{} &\log \sum b &\le \log \sum c
\end{alignat*}

produces:

I needed to add two extra alignment characters between the columns, and a {} to make the \le a binary operator. The number of &'s should be 2n-1 where n is the argument given (2 in the case above).

---

Although now that I read the question again I realize I didn't answer it. It seems that you want the \sum term to be centered...

The only way I can think of doing it is a bit ugly:

\newlength{\yuckkyhack}
\settowidth{\yuckkyhack}{$\displaystyle\log \sum b$}
\begin{alignat*}{2}
\sum a &{}\le{} &\makebox[\yuckkyhack]{$\displaystyle\sum b$} {}&\le \sum c \\
\log \sum a &\le{} &\log \sum b &\le \log \sum c
\end{alignat*}

which gives the desired result (I think):

but requires manual selection of the largest bit of text, and use of a length...any ideas for improvement?

Answer 2

Is this horse dead yet....Since my other answer got accepted, I don't want to change it. So, instead, I'm adding my thoughts here in a new answer.

---

How about this:

\begin{equation*}
\begin{aligned}\sum a &\le{}\\ \log \sum a &\le{} \end{aligned}\!
\begin{gathered}\sum b\\ \log \sum b \end{gathered}\!
\begin{aligned}{}&\le \sum c\\ {}&\le \log \sum c \end{aligned}
\end{equation*}

which produces:

No hackery involved, but the writing isn't as "linear" since you need to split the equations into columns yourself. Note also the negative space that is required to get better spacing between the columns.

Here is one more solution:

\usepackage{array}
\begin{document}

\newcolumntype{C}{>{\(\displaystyle}c<{\)}@{}} 
\newcolumntype{L}{>{\(\displaystyle}l<{\)}@{}} 
\newcolumntype{R}{>{\(\displaystyle}r<{\)}@{}}

\center{
\begin{tabular}{RCL}
\sum a \le{} & \sum b &\le \sum c \\
\log \sum a\le{} &\log \sum b &{}\le \log \sum c
\end{tabular}

\end{document}

Oh, one caveat: I have no idea how to have more than one equation number with this solution.

Answer 3

As documented in amsmath's User guide if you want to have all the equivalence symbols aligned use && for the second equivalence:

\begin{alignat}{2}
x& = y_1-y_2+y_3-y_5+y_8-\dots
                 &\quad& \text{by \eqref{eq:C}}\\
& = y’\circ y^*  && \text{by \eqref{eq:D}}\\
& = y(0) y’      && \text {by Axiom 1.}
\end{alignat}

Answer 4

Using the calc package, we can split the difference of the widths of the middle terms. We can then work either with the align or the alignat environment.

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{amsmath,calc}

\newlength\halfdiff
\setlength\halfdiff{( \widthof{$\log \sum b$} - \widthof{$\sum b$} ) / 2}

\begin{document}
\begin{align*}
\sum a      & \le \hspace{\halfdiff} \sum b \hspace{\halfdiff} \le \sum c \\
\log \sum a & \le \log \sum b                                  \le \log \sum c
\end{align*}

\begin{alignat*}{2}
\sum a      & \le \hspace{\halfdiff} \sum b && \le \sum c \\
\log \sum a & \le \log \sum b               && \le \log \sum c
\end{alignat*}
\end{document}

Answer 5

I know this has been solved for a while, but can't you just use OP's second solution with \displaystyle?

\[
\begin{array}{rcccl}
\displaystyle\sum a &\le& \displaystyle\sum b &\le& \displaystyle\sum c \\
\displaystyle\log \sum a &\le& \displaystyle\log \sum b &\le& \displaystyle\log \sum c
\end{array}
\]

Answer 6

Here's one which, funnily enough, doesn't use any align.

$$\eqalign{
\phantom{\log}\sum a \le \phantom{\log}\sum b \le \phantom{\log}\sum c \cr
         \log \sum a \le          \log \sum b \le          \log \sum c \cr
}$$

Which, I now realize, doesn't meet the requirements. Specifically, the centering of the \sum's. So in case I've now fully understood:

$$\vbox{\openup1\jot\halign{#&&\ \hfil$\displaystyle#$\hfil\cr
  &\sum a    &\leq&\sum b    &\leq&\sum c\cr
  &\log\sum a&\leq&\log\sum b&\leq&\log\sum c\cr}}$$

Answer 7

In addition to each cell being in \textstyle rather than \displaystyle, the spacing around the binary operators is quite poor. Look how wide it is as compared to the correct spacing you see for the \le on the left side of the align.

Here's one way to do what you want. I don't claim it's the best though. In fact, I'm not terribly happy about it.

\newcommand*\dmath[1]{$\mathsurround0pt\displaystyle#1$}
\newlength\equationwidth
\settowidth\equationwidth{\dmath{\log\sum b}}
\begin{align*}
\sum a&\le\makebox[\equationwidth]{\dmath{\sum b}}\le\sum c\\
\log\sum a&\le\log\sum b\le\log\sum c
\end{align*}

To be clear, I think it looks fine. I'm not happy with having to manually specify lengths.