# The definition of key default value by keyval package

For a key keya defined by

\define@key{fam}{keya}[\def\y#1{#1}]{\def\x##1{##1x#1}}


the keyval package uses

\def\KV@def#1#2[#3]#4{%
\begingroup\toks@{#3}%
\xdef\@gtempa{\expandafter\noexpand\csname KV@#1@#2\endcsname{\the\toks@}}%
\endgroup
\expandafter\let\csname KV@#1@#2@default\endcsname\@gtempa
\expandafter\def\csname KV@#1@#2\endcsname##1{#4}%
}


to define the default value as

\KV@fam@keya@default{\KV@fam@keya{defau}}


This style of defining the default value is called the standard format by the xkeyval package. Packages such fancyvrb don't adhere to this standard. The xkeyval package says that such packages abuse the default-value format.

I have always wondered why the keyval package chose to define the default value of a key in this way, instead of the apparently cheaper approach of storing the default value in a macro like

\def\KV@fam@keya@default{defau}


Without eTeX this should actually be

\newtoks\toksa
\toksa{defau}
\edef\KV@fam@keya@default{\the\toksa}


or something similar.

• Where is the question? Why don't you accept any of your questions. – Marco Daniel Feb 5 '12 at 0:07
• Where is the question? Wait for David Carlisle! Please I have clicked on the 'accept' mark/button but the red warning will not disappear. – Ahmed Musa Feb 5 '12 at 0:13
• @AhmedMusa: Be sure to not to close the page too early after clicking (give it a few seconds). If you have JavaScript disabled or blocked, enable it. – Andrey Vihrov Feb 5 '12 at 0:23