1

I know there are TeX primitives and Plain TeX macros created (directly/indirectly) by TeX primitives. My question is are there TeX macro? E. g. I can use \break in pdfTeX without defining it and \break is not a TeX primitive. Is it a TeX macro or a Plain TeX macro? Plain TeX is a format like LaTeX. Does the TeX engine load Plain TeX by default? If not \break must be a TeX macro.

  • There are primitives, and there are macros: how we 'call' the latter is something of a semantic issue. For example, LaTeX defines \centerline as in plain TeX, but it's not a documented part of LaTeX ... – Joseph Wright Oct 27 '18 at 18:57
  • Does the TeX engine load Plain TeX by default? — yes if you invoke it as tex or pdftex (in a typical TeX distribution), it does load plain TeX by default (you should see something like “preloaded format=pdftex” or “preloaded format=tex” in the first line of the program output, which are both references to plain). – ShreevatsaR Oct 27 '18 at 19:29
3

When TeX starts, it does not know a single macro, only primitives. If it runs as iniTeX, it expects to be given a file to execute (or you could enter commands interactively), and that file could (and for sure, will) define a bunch of macros. If it does not run as iniTeX, it expects to be told the name of a format file, which will also contain a bunch of macro definitions, among other things. (Normally, TeX looks at the name it is being called by to figure out what format to load.) By the way, a format file is nothing but a binary representation of the internal state of iniTeX before it executed a \dump primitive.

In particular, no, TeX does not load the plain macros by default, and no, there are no “TeX macros” the way you think there are, if I understood you correctly.

However, the LaTeX format does contain the vast majority of plain TeX macros, sometimes unchanged, sometimes in modified form.

  • When I execute pdfTeX (miktex-pdftex.exe) I can use \break macro and as the TeXbook say \break is a plain TeX macro. How does miktex-pdftex.exe know to load Plain TeX? Why are Plain TeX macro available without explicitly being loaded? The only argument of miktex-pdftex.exe is `$fullname``. – John webner Oct 27 '18 at 19:33
  • 1
    +1, but "TeX does not load the plain macros by default" might be correct in theory, although in practice the user will call something like "pdftex" which preloads plain. – TeXnician Oct 27 '18 at 19:33
  • @Johnwebner Simply start pdftex without any argument, you will drop into interactive mode and have something like preloaded format=pdftex in the first few lines. – TeXnician Oct 27 '18 at 19:34
  • As I said in my answer, if it does not run as iniTeX, it will typically look at the name it is being run as (for example, pdftex or miktex-pdftex.exe, apparently), and use that information to decide what preloaded format to load. You can override that with the command line option -fmt=…, naming the format to be loaded. – Harald Hanche-Olsen Oct 27 '18 at 21:06
  • The point made by @TeXnician (and I agree) is that statements like “When TeX starts, it does not know a single macro…” and “TeX does not load the plain macro by default” are rather misleading, because “by default” one invokes TeX as tex or pdftex or something like that; it's the -ini form (INITEX) that is rare and unusual (i.e., not the default) — calling INITEX the default is a very unconventional usage of “default” IMO; even Knuth's original design had “TEX” like present-day tex (called the “production version of TeX” in the TeX program source code), and “INITEX” was special. – ShreevatsaR Oct 27 '18 at 21:23

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.