\read\hcInputStream to \hcAuxLine
    \edef\hcAuxText{\hcAuxAcumm \hcAuxLine}

I am trying to read the contents of a file to a variable. I need the whole file to be read because the file will be later modified (like a table of contents).

When the above code is run, I get the following message:

! TeX capacity exceeded, sorry [input stack size=5000].
\@ifundefined #1->\expandafter \ifx \csname #1
                                              \endcsname \relax \expandafter..

I would like to know i) why that code overflows the stack, and ii) is there a better way to read a whole file to a variable?

%%%%%%%%%% Edit %%%%%%%%%%

The ulterior motives for this code are to load a file into a variable which can then be "pasted" whenever used. The file is read \AtBeginDocument but it is modified when the source is processed. So, I want to keep the "initial state" of the file in memory. That might help with my question (ii) above.

As for part (i), I am baffled that the code above did not work. After all, I read a line storing it in \hcAuxLine, copy the previous state of \hcAuxAcumm to \hcAuxText, and finally concatenate {\hcAuxAcumm \hcAuxLine} to \hcAuxText.

  • Is that all of the code you have? Your error indicates that you are using LaTeX but the snippet is pure plain TeX. – Joseph Wright Dec 12 '10 at 17:04
  • Unfortunately, I do not know enough of either TeX or LaTeX to decide for the best tool, so I mix and match. The output of this routine is to be used as \hcAuxText and it should give the same result as \input{myfile.tmp}, except that myfile.tmp was written in between. – Hector Dec 12 '10 at 17:06

Taking it that the topic here is LaTeX, I'd look at the catchfile package. As to the message you get, it's a bit hard to be sure without some more context. I do wonder about using \edef here, though. It will fully expand the line that has just been read from the file, which may be a bad idea. This is a general point, and I'd at the very least consider using \protected@edef. If you don't want expansion, I'd suggest you're better avoiding it entirely. As you are using e-TeX, you'd be better with


By the way, there is no need to make a copy of \hcAuxText for the \edef step. A line such as

\edef\hcAuxText{\hcAuxText <extra stuff}

will expand \hcAuxText within the definition before the assignment.

  • catchfile did the trick, thank you! For the record, catchfile's content must have a "complete" command. If catchfile contained something like "\item a" then it fails. It must have something like "\begin{itemize}\item a\end{itemize}". ... As for the difference between \def and \edef, I thought they were like Mathematica's Rule and RuleDelayed, but it seems like there is more to it. – Hector Dec 12 '10 at 17:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.