7

I already read questions about recommended packages, and they often have the advice for

\RequirePackage[l2tabu, orthodox]{nag}

and

\usepackage[all, warning]{onlyamsmath}

I use nag for quite some time now and am unsure if I still need onlyamsmath. My question: as far as I understand, nag already does everything and more that onlyamsmath is doing when it comes to math environments (warn about "bad" math environments), is this correct?

So, does onlyamsmath bring any further advantage if I already use nag? I don't need the error functionality of onlyamsmath, only the warnings.

7

OK, I found some time to test this out. I tested everything that onlyamsmath mentioned in its documentation, assuming the documentation is complete. The following code:

\RequirePackage[l2tabu, orthodox]{nag}
\documentclass[fleqn]{scrreprt}

%\usepackage[all, warning]{onlyamsmath}

\begin{document}

$$a = b$$

\begin{eqnarray}
  a = b
\label{eq:foo1}
\end{eqnarray}

\begin{eqnarray*}
  a = b
\label{eq:foo2}
\end{eqnarray*}

\begin{displaymath}
  a = b
\end{displaymath}

\end{document}

Generates these warnings:

Package nag Warning: $$...$$ is obsolete.
(nag)                Use \[...\] et al. instead on input line 8.

Package nag Warning: Environment eqnarray is obsolete. 
(nag)                Use amsmath's align instead on input line 10.

Package nag Warning: Environment eqnarray is obsolete. 
(nag)                Use amsmath's align instead on input line 15.

And now commenting out nag and commenting in onlyamsmath produces these warnings:

Package onlyamsmath Warning: Environment $$ $$ used, please use 
(onlyamsmath)                only the environments provided by the amsmath 
(onlyamsmath)                package on input line 8.

Package onlyamsmath Warning: Environment eqnarray or eqnarray* used, please use 
(onlyamsmath)                only the environments provided by the amsmath 
(onlyamsmath)                package on input line 10.

Package onlyamsmath Warning: Environment eqnarray or eqnarray* used, please use 
(onlyamsmath)                only the environments provided by the amsmath 
(onlyamsmath)                package on input line 15.

Package onlyamsmath Warning: Environment displaymath used, please use 
(onlyamsmath)                only the environments provided by the amsmath 
(onlyamsmath)                package on input line 20.

If you use both at the same time, only onlyamsmath will complain about $$...$$, but nag will not. eqnarray will be warned about by both packages at the same time. displaymath is only complained about by onlyamsmath in all cases.

Conclusion: Yes, onlyamsmath does detect something that nag won't detect (displaymath).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.