I am using chicago.sty to reference papers. At one point, I have to reference two papers with the same first author and the same year. I don't want to use the cite option that shows all the authors. Instead I would like something like "Smith et al. (2009a)" and "Smith et al. (2009b)".

Is there a way I can do this (without changing to natbib)?

Here is an example:


                 shortcite     & \shortcite{Smith2012}      
                 citeyear      & \citeyear{Smith2012}  \\        

                 shortcite     & \shortcite{Smith2012b}                  
                 citeyear      & \citeyear{Smith2012b}    
  • 1
    Welcome to TeX.sx! I can't help but to suggest you consider moving to biblatex, which has chicago style (biblatex-chicago)
    – henrique
    Nov 30 '12 at 15:51
  • Thank you @henrique, but I have tried that before, and could not get citeyear to work. I will try it again.
    – Sara
    Nov 30 '12 at 15:55

Although you specifically asked for a bibtex solution for the chicago package, I couldn't resist to point you to biblatex, since Chicago Manual of Style biblatex style files are provided by the biblatex-chicago package.

To change the number of authors that trigger the "et al." string in biblatex, you have the options maxnames and minnames. Setting them to 1 takes care of your request (it is worth noting, however, that according to biblatex-chicago manual, this is not recommended by the Chicago Manual of Style). These options can be passed to biblatex-chicago package.

You mentioned in your comments not getting \citeyear to work in biblatex; this might be because \citeyear only prints the year field, without the extra label that is appended to disambiguate it. But this is achievable by the \citeyear* command.

N.B.: Please notice that biblatex-chicago (v. 0.9.9.a) requires biber for its author-year style, as stated in the manual (§2):

[Biber] is required for users who are either using the author-date style or processing a .bib file in Unicode.

That means you should replace the bibtex pass for a biber one. Compile this with [pdf]latexbiber[pdf]latex[pdf]latex

Here's a MWE:

  author = {A. Smith and B. Schmidt},
  title = {A title},
  journal = {A Journal},
  year = {2012},
  author = {A. Smith and B. Schmidt},
  title = {Another title},
  journal = {Another Journal},
  year = {2012},


\verb!autocite! is the main citation command: it knows if it is in text or in notes, and switches between \verb!\footcite! and \verb!\parencite! accordingly. \autocite[1]{Smith2012}, \autocite[1]{Smith2012b}

\verb!\footcite! is for citations on footnotes\footcite[1]{Smith2012}, \footcite[1]{Smith2012b}

\verb!\parencite! is for citations in parentheses \parencite[1]{Smith2012}, \parencite[1]{Smith2012b}

\verb!\textcite! is for inline citations, like \textcite[1]{Smith2012}, \textcite[1]{Smith2012b}

\verb!\citeyear! cites only the \verb!year! field, not \verb!year+label!: \citeyear[1]{Smith2012b}. To cite the whole label, you should try the starred variant \verb!\citeyear*!: \citeyear*[1]{Smith2012}, \citeyear*{Smith2012b}

You can also have multiple citations with some of these commands: \autocites{Smith2012}{Smith2012b}


And the output:

biblatex-chicago example

  • Thank you, but I do not get the same output as you with your code. I am getting some errors when executing bibtex: found no \citations commands, found no \bibdata command, found no \bibstyle command. This happens even if I move the bibliography to another file. I had this error before, and that is why I changed to chicago.sty
    – Sara
    Nov 30 '12 at 16:45
  • Please, ignore the former comment, I've checked biblatex-chicago manual again, and it requires biber. Simply switch to biber in the bibtex pass.
    – henrique
    Nov 30 '12 at 17:00
  • I will try that. I am using Texniccenter, so first I will have to check how to do it. I will get back to you.
    – Sara
    Nov 30 '12 at 17:06
  • Ok, I updated the answer to mention that. For running biber form TeXnicCenter, check this question (but, instead of bibtex, search for the path to biber executable)
    – henrique
    Nov 30 '12 at 17:10
  • It worked! I had to update biber for it to work though....Thanks!!
    – Sara
    Nov 30 '12 at 18:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.